Disadvantages of a C Corporation
Double
taxation is a term you will often hear as a major disadvantage of a C Corp. In
some circumstances, C Corp profits will be subject to "double
taxation". For example, if a C
Corp generates profits, it will have to pay taxes on those profits (1st
time taxed). Next, because of the profits, a C Corp may issue dividends
(distribution to Shareholders/Owners) as a return on their investment. Once
distributed to the Shareholder/Owner, the Shareholder/Owner will also have to
pay tax on the distribution when they report the distribution on their personal
income tax return (2nd time taxed), thus profits have been doubled
taxed. Also, if the owner(s) of the Corporation are also paid salaries from the
C Corp�s profits, they will be taxed on their wages from the C Corp on their
personal return (2nd time taxed). The C Corp has to pay taxes on the
profits and the Shareholder/Owner has to pay taxes on the distribution/wages of
profits they received from the C Corp.
Also,
C Corps cannot pass through losses to Shareholders/Owners like a Sole
Proprietorship or a Partnership. Thus the Shareholders/Owners cannot reduce
their personal taxes by losses incurred by the C Corp.
Lastly, C Corp is the most
complicated Business Structure to set up. C Corps must follow all of the
corporate formalities including filing various documents with the State, the
notice and holding of board meetings and the maintenance of records. Numerous
regulations and requirements must be upheld by the C Corp to remain in good
standing with the applicable State government agency, failure to do so will
result in the suspension of the C Corp�s ability to do business in the State.
Banks may close the C Corp�s bank account(s) and lenders can call for immediate
payment on their loans if a C Corp is suspended from doing business in the
State.
When considering a C Corp,
it is imperative that the C Corp is set up properly with the State. Please
contact us for free consultation regarding the incorporation of your business.
S Corporation (S Corp)
Definition
An S Corp is a C Corp that
made a timely election with the IRS to become a S Corp. Like a C Corp, an S
Corp is generally a Corporation under the law of the State in which the entity
is organized. Please see below for Advantages and Disadvantages.
Personal Liability
S Corporations are separate
legal entities from their Shareholders and, under State laws, generally provide
their Shareholders with the same liability protection afforded to the Shareholders
of C Corp.
Income Tax Treatment
Federal: S Corp resembles a Partnership, the net
income or losses of an S Corp flow through to Shareholders based on the
Shareholders applicable interest in the S Corp. The Shareholder�s report their
share of income or losses of the S Corp on their personal income tax returns.
The S Corp does not pay taxes on income or losses.
State: S Corp are exempt
from State income taxes.
S Corp Elections
To be recognized as a S
Corp for tax purposes, the C Corp must meet the following requirements:
- Must be an eligible entity (a domestic Corporation, or a Limited Liability Company).
- Must have only one class of
stock.
- Must not have more than 100
shareholders.
- Shareholders must be U.S.
citizens or residents, and must be physical entities (a person), so
Corporate Shareholders and partnerships are to be excluded.
- Profits and losses must be
allocated to Shareholders proportionately to each one's interest in the
business.
If a corporation meets the
foregoing requirements and wishes to be taxed under Subchapter S, its Shareholders
may file
Form 2553:
"Election by a Small Business Corporation" with the
Internal Revenue Service (IRS). The Form 2553 must
be signed by all of the Corporation's Shareholders. If a Shareholder resides in
a
community
property state, the shareholder's spouse generally must also sign
the 2553.
The S corporation election
must typically be made by the fifteenth day of the third month of the tax year
for which the election is intended to be effective, or at any time during the
year immediately preceding the tax year. Congress has directed the IRS to show
leniency with regard to late S elections
Advantages of a S Corp
Since a S Corp is a
separate legal entity, it is responsible for its own liabilities, debts and
legal claims. Usually Shareholders, Directors or Officers are not liable for
the liabilities, debts or legal claims of the S Corp. In other words, their
personal assets are protected.
As a separate legal entity,
a S Corp can operate indefinitely. The death of a Shareholder does not affect
the legal status of a S Corp.
Becoming a S Corp can also
reduce or eliminate self employment taxes for business owners who own their own
business. Distribution of income, generated by the S Corp to business owners,
can be classified as dividends. Dividends are not subject to self employment
taxes. Distributions, under a Sole Proprietorship, would be subject to self
employment taxes.
Disadvantages of a S
Corp
Setting up a S Corp is
complicated and requires familiarity with State regulations. Furthermore,
numerous regulations and requirements must be upheld by the S Corp to remain in
good standing with the applicable State government agency, failure to do so
will result in the suspension of the S Corp�s ability to do business in the
State,
Please contact us for free
consultation regarding a S Corp status.
Limited Liability Company (LLC)
Definition
A LLC is a relatively new Business Structure; it was not until 1988 that
the IRS agreed to treat LLCs as Partnerships for tax purposes. Although
recognized by the IRS for tax purposes, the LLC Business Structure is purely a
creature of State law. It was designed by State legislatures to overcome the
limitations of each of the other Business Structures. Forming an LLC has become a popular
alternative for Sole Proprietors and Partnerships that have thought about
forming a Corporation in order to protect personal assets.
The owners of LLCs are typically referred to as Members and most States
allow single Member companies.
Personal Liability
If structured and managed correctly, legally the Members of an LLC are
not personally liable for the company�s liabilities, debts and legal claims. An
LLC affords the same personal legal liability protection that is offered to
Shareholders of a C Corporation.
Like the
shareholders of a C Corporation, Members of an LLC have limited liability for
business debts. If the LLC is properly structured and managed, each Member�s
personal assets will be protected from lawsuits and judgments against the
business, so each Member�s liability is limited to the amount each has invested
in the company. Forming
an LLC as your business structure will separate your personal identity from
your business identity.
Income Tax Treatment
Federal Income Taxes: An LLC may elect to be treated as a Sole
Proprietorship, Partnership or Corporation. In order to elect the Partnership
treatment, the LLC must have at least two members. Related tax treatment will
be applied according to the Business Structure elected by the LLC.
State Income Taxes: Tax treatment will be applied according to the Business
Structure the LLC elects.
Advantages of a Limited Liability Company
The LLC is basically a hybrid Business Structure that provides the
limited liability features of a Corporation and the tax efficiencies and
operational flexibility of a Sole Proprietorship or Partnership. Members are
normally not personally responsible for the LLC�s liabilities, debts or legal
claims.
The Management structure is more flexible than a Corporation, as the LLC may be managed either
directly by its Members, by a manager who may be one of the Members or by
someone hired by the Members to manage the business. Members can also elect the tax treatment that is the
most advantage for them.
Most States allow single Member (ie one owner) LLC companies and there
is no restriction on the maximum number of Members. Furthermore, most States
allow an easy conversion into another business structure.
Also, there are limited formalities; LLCs are not required to hold
annual meetings and draft minutes like a Corporation.
Potential
customers may perceive an LLC as a more professional entity than a Sole
Proprietorship or Partnership.
Disadvantages
of an LLC
There is
some paper work and cost involved with setting up an LLC. Legal documents
called Articles of Organization must be filed with the Secretary of State or
other designated State agencies. The Articles of Organization sets forth basic
information about the LLC like names, addresses, processing agent, term, and
whether the Members will be managing the LLC or managers appointed by the
Members will be managing the LLC.
In
addition, some States require the LLC to file an Operating Agreement, which is
similar to a Partnership Agreement. It provides important details on how the
LLC will operate, financial obligation of each Member, and how profits and
losses will be allocated to its Members.
Please
feel free to contact us to set up your LLC.